- Starmer’s government faces criticism over stalled ethics reforms and internal Labour Party unrest.
- Early housing and mortgage initiatives drew praise, but welfare changes sparked rebellion.
- Public trust wavers amid policy U-turns, donor controversies, and diluted reform pledges.
One year into his premiership, Sir Keir Starmer finds himself navigating a storm of skepticism and unmet expectations. Though Labour swept into power on a wave of hope, promising ethical leadership and social justice, its early months have been marred by scandal and indecision.
On policy, Labour has made efforts to address the housing crisis, with Chancellor Rachel Reeves unveiling billions for affordable and social housing. These pledges were welcomed by mortgage professionals, who praised the direction but called for more depth.
Starmer’s Struggle: One Year of Power, Pressure, and Party Fractures
The failure to follow through on key transparency and anti-corruption reforms has weakened Labour’s credibility. While Starmer once championed tougher rules on political lobbying and post-ministerial conduct, watchdogs remain toothless, and many reforms have been kicked down the road. Critics argue Labour is repeating old patterns—prioritising political expediency over systemic change.
Meanwhile, Labour’s approach to immigration has taken a pragmatic, if controversial, turn. The government claims diplomatic progress with France in tackling small boat crossings, suggesting improved cross-border cooperation. However, crossings have continued at record levels, casting doubt on the effectiveness of these so-called “reset” relations.
Within the party, ideological divisions are hardening. Starmer’s centrist direction clashes with Labour’s grassroots expectations. The exit of prominent left-wing MPs and growing dissatisfaction with welfare policy are signs of deeper identity tensions. With figures like Angela Rayner, Liz Kendall, and Rachel Reeves jockeying for influence, Labour risks fragmentation unless a unified strategy emerges.
Lastly, Labour’s handling of political donations and transparency remains under scrutiny. The continued role of mega-donors and unregulated money flows—along with a watered-down elections bill—suggest a reluctance to challenge the status quo. The perception that Labour is protecting donor interests undermines its pledge to “clean up” politics and invites accusations of hypocrisy.
Keir Starmer’s first year in power reflects a government caught between ambition and caution. If Labour hopes to maintain its mandate, it must act decisively to rebuild trust, restore party unity, and deliver the bold reforms it once promised.
“The price of greatness is responsibility.” – Winston Churchill
